Skip to content

init google scaffold generates incorrect networks INSERT and statecheck #59

Description

@nirmalpatel008

Summary

The Google scaffold generated by stackql-deploy init google contains two issues in the generated VPC resource definition:

  1. The google.compute.networks.insert statement does not use the method-specific data__ fields required for the request body.
  2. The generated statecheck compares autoCreateSubnetworks with false, which did not match the deployed resource in my validation. Comparing it with 0 worked correctly.

After correcting both, I successfully validated the complete stackql-deploy build flow against a real GCP project.

Reproduction

Generate a Google stack:

stackql-deploy init google

Then run the generated stack with a valid GCP project.

The generated network resource contains an INSERT similar to:

INSERT INTO google.compute.networks
(project, name, autoCreateSubnetworks, routingConfig)
SELECT
  '{{ project }}',
  '{{ vpc_name }}',
  false,
  '{"routingMode": "REGIONAL"}';

When executed against google.compute.networks.insert, this resulted in a GCP HTTP 400 response:

Required field 'resource' not specified

Issue 1: generated INSERT fields

For this provider method, project is the path parameter, while the request-body fields use the data__ prefix.

The working INSERT is:

INSERT INTO google.compute.networks
(project, data__name, data__autoCreateSubnetworks, data__routingConfig)
SELECT
  '{{ project }}',
  '{{ vpc_name }}',
  false,
  '{"routingMode": "REGIONAL"}';

The method contract can be inspected directly with:

DESCRIBE METHOD google.compute.networks.insert;

Provider reference:

https://google-provider.stackql.io/services/compute/networks#insert-examples

The Google provider itself is working correctly; this appears to be an issue with the generated init google scaffold for this resource.

Issue 2: generated statecheck

The generated statecheck contains:

AND autoCreateSubnetworks = false

During validation, this returned no matching row even though the VPC had autoCreateSubnetworks disabled.

Changing it to:

AND autoCreateSubnetworks = 0

matched the deployed resource correctly and allowed the statecheck to pass.

End-to-end validation

After applying both changes, the stack completed successfully through the full resource lifecycle:

exists
create
statecheck
exports
successfully deployed resource
build complete

The deployment completed successfully against a real GCP project.

Expected behavior

A project generated by:

stackql-deploy init google

should produce a working scaffold that can be built without manually correcting the generated SQL.

For the generated Compute Network resource, the scaffold should:

  • use the method-specific data__ fields required by google.compute.networks.insert
  • generate a statecheck expression that correctly matches the returned autoCreateSubnetworks value

Root cause

The issue is in the generated Google scaffold for the Compute Network resource, rather than the stackql-deploy runtime or the Google provider specification.

The provider issue originally opened during diagnosis has been closed after confirming the provider method works correctly with the proper INSERT contract.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions